Among other aspects of my identity, I am a Christian and a Social Worker. Both of these pieces of my identity help me make values based decisions, including my thoughts on capital punishment.
I have utmost empathy for victims of violent crime and for their surviving family members. I cannot imagine the pain they have experienced. I never want to imagine myself in that situation. And, in the recognition that “two can be true” at the same time…I do not think the state sanctioned execution of someone is justice. It is retribution, a paying back, an “eye for an eye”.
Justice work is constant, a steady stream, a continuous protecting, and, when necessary, a re-weaving of the social fabric of community. Justice would be preventing children from experiencing torture by the people entrusted to care from them. Justice would include recognizing the way that experiencing chronic trauma would change your brain development, especially as a child. Justice would recognize that life without parole can hold someone accountable for their actions without enacting the ultimate harm. Capital punishment has legal and spiritual shortcomings, to say the very (very) least. I have asked my Tennessee governor for clemency in a specific case this week, and I have made the same requests before in other situations. I have no confidence he listens but I can’t not try.

I used to have an assignment in one of my classes that involved students giving a persuasive speech on a social issue of concern to them. It is a macro social work practice class, so part of what they are learning is how to bring about change in “big systems”. So, the purpose of the assignment is for them to think about a cause they are passionate about, and then think about an audience and an “ask”…something you are asking the audience to do to be a part of big system change.
Because I don’t ask them to do something I am not willing to do, I have an example ready to deliver each semester we use this assignment. Mine is on the death penalty. I have cared about this issue for a lot of years. I am not eloquent enough or legally smart enough to say more. But I do believe in the sovreignty of life, from womb to tomb, and I try to live that out in whatever small ways I can.
Here is a copy of my persuasive speech, from the last time I used it in fall semester 2025.
Audience: leaders of independent faith communities, Davidson County Religious Leaders
Thank you for allowing me to be present with you today. I am here to talk about capital punishment here in the state of Tennessee. I come to you as a social worker interested in social justice issues, as a member of the group Tennesseans for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, and also as a person of faith.
Tennessee’s last execution of a prisoner was August 5th, just a few weeks ago, and the 15th execution since 2000. There are 43 people on death row in Tennessee. There are two dates set for execution: September 24th and December 11th.
The issue of capital punishment has many dimensions: legal, financial, social, and spiritual. Legally, there is no clear evidence that the use of capital punishment as a sentencing option is a deterrent for others who would commit serious offenses as a 2024 report show that the states with the highest murder rates all practice capital punishment. Financially, we know that the economic cost of sentencing someone to death is significantly more than seeking life imprisonment. This is true nationally and is true in our own state as well. Capital murder trials are longer and more expensive at every step compared to other murder trials, and death penalty trials cost an average of 48 percent more than the cost of trials in which prosecutors seek life imprisonment.
Socially, there are many justice issues to consider. The risk of executing the innocent can never be fully eliminated because the justice system, orchestrated by humans, is fallible. Since 1973, at least 200 people who were on death row were later exonerated and we don’t know the number of people who were executed wrongly because the courts don’t examine claims of innocence for people who are deceased. The sentence of death is also applied inconsistently at its best and unfairly at its worst, leaving us to interpret that the lives of some victims are worth more than others, and the lives of some murderers are worth more than others.
Spiritually, executing someone because of an act he or she has committed denies the possibility of redemption. Executions appeal to our desire for vengeance, but are a very flawed way to bring about grace and peace.
Today, it is my hope that you will join with members from other faith groups, along with other community groups, and add your names to those who are calling for abolition of the death penalty in Tennessee. I encourage you to bring this issue to your own faith community. Study it. Seek counsel. Talk with others who are struggling with this issue. Establish relationships with those who have been the victims of violent crime, as well as with those who have perpetrated it. Ultimately, I hope that you will, collectively, communicate with the governor and ask him to halt all executions while we work to pass legislation to abolish the death penalty in our state.
Thank you for your time today, and I would be happy to answer any questions you may have, now or in the future.
Here are some good sources to look at concerns related to capital punishment and advocacy resources:
People of Faith Against the Death Penalty










